Justin Tucker’s future in Baltimore looks shaky as the team quietly prepare to dump him amidst his off-field scandal and on-field decline

Justin Tucker has long been considered the gold standard for NFL kickers—a player whose consistency and clutch performances once made him one of the most automatic weapons in the league. But as the Baltimore Ravens prepare for a pivotal 2025 season, the once-untouchable star finds himself surrounded by growing uncertainty, both on and off the field.

Justin Tucker is currently under investigation after multiple massage therapists—sixteen in total—came forward with allegations of misconduct during sessions that allegedly occurred between 2012 and 2016. Tucker has denied the claims, but the NFL is taking the matter seriously and has launched a formal inquiry.

While the Ravens haven’t taken a public stance or rushed to judgment, they’ve made it clear they’re monitoring the situation closely. “They are going to wait and see how things play out before making any decisions,” a source familiar with the situation said. The gravity of the accusations has already impacted Tucker’s reputation, regardless of the final outcome. Even if cleared, the stain of the controversy may linger in the eyes of fans and the franchise alike.

Compounding the off-field scrutiny is Justin Tucker’s sharp decline in performance last season. He made only 22 of 30 field goal attempts—an uncharacteristically low 73 percent. For most kickers, that’s below average. For Tucker, it’s almost unthinkable. He also missed multiple extra points, and his once-reliable long-range power has seemingly faded.

This downturn has the Ravens exploring their options. The team recently held a private workout with Florida State standout Ryan Fitzgerald, who went a perfect 13-for-13 last season and showed serious range. They’re also rumored to be vetting veteran free agents, signaling they’re not ruling out a change at kicker.
Also Read: "Don’t ever disrespect Kamara like that": Cam Skattebo's NFL comparisons spark debate as insiders urge for more realistic player parallels
For now, Justin Tucker remains on the roster. But the writing may be on the wall. While his contributions to the Ravens franchise are immense, NFL front offices are driven by performance, not past glories. If the legal issues escalate or his on-field struggles continue, Baltimore could be forced to part ways with one of its most iconic players.
Whether Justin Tucker gets a chance to redeem himself or the team moves in a new direction, one thing is clear—his grip on the kicker job is no longer ironclad.