Shannon Sharpe’s ESPN return in jeopardy—network backs off star analyst over ongoing sexual assault lawsuit

Shannon Sharpe’s expected return to ESPN’s First Take has hit a roadblock due to serious legal issues and internal discussions at the network. In April 2025, Sharpe voluntarily stepped away, stating he would return by the NFL preseason. At the time, he aimed to show confidence in resolving the matter quickly and clearing his name.

However, the situation has grown more complicated. Shannon Sharpe is facing a $50 million civil lawsuit filed by Gabriella Zuniga, an OnlyFans model, who accuses him of rape and emotional distress stemming from a 2024 incident. While Sharpe maintains the relationship was consensual and has presented text messages as evidence, the accuser’s legal team has released audio allegedly featuring him making threatening remarks.
According to Outkick, Sharpe's return to ESPN is "no guarantee." “He is emphatic that he is innocent of those things," said Stephen A. Smith about Sharpe on Thursday, in an appearance on the "BigBoyTV" podcast. “But the court of public opinion is what the Disneys of the world and others concern themselves with. That’s a more immediate issue. And unfortunately, that has worked against him at this particular moment in time."

“I know the brother tells me he’s innocent, I believe him," Smith said. "I know that he does not trust easy, and that honest conversations that he’s had with me he wouldn’t have with just anybody."
Despite his strong personal support for Sharpe, Smith made it clear that the situation is bigger than just personal belief. ESPN, as a major media company, is under pressure to handle the matter with caution given the seriousness of the allegations. While Smith values the trust and honesty Sharpe has shown him in private, he also acknowledged that the company has a responsibility to its audience and brand image.
Internally, ESPN is continuing its review process and has not committed to bringing Sharpe back just yet. The network is reportedly weighing legal risks, public perception, and the potential fallout of Sharpe’s return if the case progresses further or gains more media attention.
Meanwhile, Sharpe remains confident in his innocence and has pledged to clear his name. His legal team has already released personal communications with the accuser to support his claims. However, with audio recordings presented by the opposing side and past accusations resurfacing, the situation remains complicated.
Also Read: Shannon Sharpe at the center of fresh controversy as cryptic post hint at secret damage control amid $50 million sexual assault lawsuit
As ESPN evaluates its next steps, potential replacements for Sharpe are being considered, with Jason Kelce emerging as a frontrunner due to his popularity and media potential. Whether Sharpe returns or not will depend on the outcome of both the legal process and ESPN’s internal decisions in the coming weeks.