NHL playoff controversy: Brandon Hagel injury raises questions about league's double standards

It was supposed to be just another hard-fought battle in the heated Battle of Florida playoff series, but Game 4 between the Tampa Bay Lightning and Florida Panthers took a troubling turn when Brandon Hagel was forced out of the game after a high hit from Aaron Ekblad, a hit that surprisingly went unpenalized.
Fans, analysts, and even players were left asking: where’s the consistency when it comes to player safety in the NHL playoffs?


Midway through the second period, Hagel was skating along the boards, moving the puck out of the Lightning zone, when Panthers defenseman Aaron Ekblad delivered a high hit that made clear contact with Hagel’s head. The collision caused Hagel to hit the ice hard, the back of his head bouncing violently. Medical staff immediately pulled him due to concussion concerns. He did not return. And yet, there was no whistle. No penalty. No review.
For a league that talks a big game about protecting its players, this was a major miss. The hit looked dangerous in real time and even worse in slow motion, yet it didn’t earn even a second glance from officials.
Just one game earlier, Hagel himself was suspended for interference on Panthers captain Aleksander Barkov. The NHL ruled that Barkov wasn’t eligible to be hit, and Hagel made head contact. He was suspended one game, his first career suspension. Barkov returned the next game. Hagel, however, returned in Game 4, only to be taken out by a questionable hit with no consequence.

Tampa Bay coach Jon Cooper didn’t hold back after the loss. “It’s getting tiresome answering questions about a hit every single game,” he said bluntly, pointing out the lack of accountability from the league.
And he’s not wrong. The NHL’s inconsistency in enforcing discipline, especially during high-stakes playoff games is becoming a glaring issue. Fans and players alike are voicing concerns. While Brandon Hagel’s hit drew a suspension, Aaron Ekblad’s hit resulted in zero action from the NHL’s Department of Player Safety, sparking outrage on social media and beyond.
Ekblad, ironically, had just returned from a 20-game suspension for PED use. In his comeback, he scores a goal and delivers a controversial hit that knocks out one of the league’s top two-way forwards yet the league remains silent.

The Panthers lead the series 3-1, but the bigger story is the growing distrust in how the NHL handles dangerous plays, late hits, and controversial non-calls. This wasn’t just a missed call, it was a missed opportunity to uphold player safety, ensure accountability, and enforce fair standards across the league. Fans are demanding consistency, especially when star players are targeted with no repercussions.
Also Read: Mike Sullivan out as Penguins Head Coach
As Game 5 heads to Tampa, tensions are high. Fans, analysts, and players alike are wondering whether the NHL is truly serious about protecting its stars, or does the intense Stanley Cup playoff spotlight mean the rulebook gets thrown out? Suspensions, penalties, player safety, and league transparency are all on the line as the series heats up.