These two dog breeds will be banned in Goa: Here's what pet lovers have to say

In a bold move that has sparked intense debate, the Goa State Cabinet has announced a ban on Rottweilers and Pitbull Terriers. Chief Minister Pramod Sawant revealed this decision, citing serious public safety concerns following several distressing incidents involving these breeds. The ban will prevent the import, sale, and breeding of these dogs in Goa, raising important questions about the impact on pet owners and animal welfare. As the government takes steps to enhance safety, pet lovers are expressing their opinions on whether this is the right approach or if it unfairly targets certain breeds.
The cabinet's decision was made during a meeting on Wednesday, where Chief Minister Sawant stated that current owners of Rottweilers and Pitbulls must register their pets with the state. They will be required to sign an affidavit accepting full responsibility for any harm caused by their dogs. “Those who already own these dogs will have to state that they take full responsibility that the dog will not bite, harm anybody. None will be able to import these breeds henceforth into Goa,” Sawant explained. This regulation will be added to the Goa Animal Breeding, Domestic Regulations, and Compensation Ordinance, 2024.
This ban comes in response to a tragic incident in August 2024 when a seven-year-old boy was killed by a Pitbull in Anjuna while visiting a neighbour with his mother. The incident has led to widespread outrage and prompted discussions about the ownership of aggressive dog breeds. Additionally, there have been reports of other attacks involving Rottweilers and Pitbulls, which have encouraged animal rights groups like PETA India to push for stricter regulations.

Public safety concerns
Under the new rules, existing owners of Rottweilers and Pitbulls will need to register their pets with the Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Services Department (AHVS). This registration aims to monitor these breeds in the state and ensure compliance with safety measures. Chief Minister Sawant had said that this initiative is crucial for public safety, "Because of somebody’s hobby, it is not right that a poor person loses his life. We will not tolerate such things."
While many see the government's decision as necessary for public safety, it has faced criticism from pet lovers and dog trainers. Some argue that banning specific breeds does not address the underlying causes of aggressive behaviour in dogs.
What the pet lovers have to say?
Shantanu Das, a techie who is working remotely in Goa's Margao states "These breed of dogs are usually bought as status symbols or show-offs, with consequences of abuse or neglect for worsened aggressive tendencies. To make the world safer for both humans and pets, it is important to have strict controls imposed and education, along with other alternatives to end this cycle of cruelty."
Vishaka Padhke, a golden retriever owner adds, “Government intervention in pet ownership is unfair, as it punishes responsible owners for the mistakes of a few. Dog owners must take responsibility for their animals and see to it that others in the area are not troubled by their pet.”
Tamanaah Shetty of Andheri, Mumbai says "As a community, we've got to make difficult decisions for the welfare of all. Stopping particular dog breeds is an extremely crucial way to prevent illegal breeding as well as to safeguard the public. We must consider the safety of our communities above the interests of a few irresponsible owners." While the ban aims to enhance public safety, it raises critical questions about fairness, enforcement, and the broader implications for responsible dog ownership in Goa.