Are the Jets setting themselves up for disaster? Ignoring defensive tackles in record-breaking NFL Draft could be a colossal mistake

The 2025 NFL Draft wrapped up in Green Bay, Wisconsin, and while most teams aggressively addressed key needs, the New York Jets made a puzzling decision that could haunt them during the upcoming season. Despite a record 30 defensive tackles being selected — the most ever in a seven-round draft — the Jets surprisingly opted not to draft a single one.

With the middle of their defensive line a glaring weakness in 2024, many expected the Jets to target a young, high-upside defensive tackle early in the draft. Instead, New York will rely on low-cost veterans Derrick Nnadi, Byron Cowart, and Jay Tufele to line up next to All-Pro Quinnen Williams. It's a gamble that feels even riskier considering the Jets' run defense ranked among the NFL's worst last season.
It’s clear the Jets believe they can "squeeze some production" out of their new veteran trio, but none of these players have been consistent impact starters in recent years. Nnadi, once a reliable run-stuffer in Kansas City, has seen his performance decline. Cowart and Tufele, meanwhile, have bounced around the league without ever cementing starting roles. Simply put, this strategy hinges on hope more than proven production.

Adding to the pressure is the need for a major leap from second-year defensive tackle Leonard Taylor III. After a quiet rookie campaign, Taylor is expected to develop into a key rotational player — if not a starter — to stabilize the interior. Banking on a sophomore breakout, especially from a player who showed limited flashes as a rookie, adds another layer of uncertainty to New York's defensive strategy.
Meanwhile, teams across the league aggressively stockpiled interior defensive linemen, reinforcing a position that has grown increasingly vital against modern NFL offenses. In contrast, the Jets' approach feels reactive rather than proactive, raising concerns about how well the defense will hold up over a grueling 17-game schedule.
Also Read: Kansas City Chiefs’ left tackle disaster continues and raises red flags: Will Jaylon Moore and Josh Simmons sink Patrick Mahomes?
For a team looking to make a deep playoff push, patching up a major defensive weakness with bargain-bin veterans and unproven young talent is a risky formula. If New York's defensive front falters again against the run, critics will undoubtedly point to their draft weekend inaction. The Jets’ bold bet on experience over fresh talent could either prove shrewd — or become one of the most second-guessed decisions of the 2025 season.